Democracy Arsenal

« When Pro-Western Regimes Fall: What Should the U.S. Do? | Main | Accommodating Pakistan's Interests in Afghanistan »

January 13, 2011

A More Civil Discourse -- Foreign Policy Wonks' Edition
Posted by David Shorr

As the country gropes for ways to lower the temperature and make political disagreement less disagreeable, I thought I'd look back to a 2006-07 initiative that brought together a bipartisan group of 20 foreign policy experts. The Stanley Foundation's Bridging the Foreign Policy Divide project was the brainchild of Derek Chollet, who is about to move from the State Department Office of Policy Planning to the White House NSC staff. Together with our our conservative friend and colleague Policy Review Editor Tod Lindberg, we recruited ten bipartisan pairs of co-authors who were commissioned to find points of agreement on different areas of policy.

In the preface for the resulting book, I explained how the project worked and offered some reflections on foreign policy bipartisanship and the possibility for a more constructive debate about policy. I quote a couple passages below, but if you'd like to read the preface, it's pages ix-xiii at Google Books.

Here's how I described our consensus-seeking enterprise:

Politics today leaves little room for deliberation over issues; by and large, it is total war between sworn enemites. Rather than winning arguments on the particular merits of a matter, each side seeks to thoroughly discredit the other. As a result, what the public sees primarly are the caricatures that both parties draw to define their counterparts.

and

As a shared frustration with the low level of political discourse, many of the essays set aside the false choices that many politicians have sought to use as domestic political wedges: international law or power realities, China as partner or adversary, arms control regimes or the direct disruption of some nations' efforts to acquire the bomb, preservation of due process or the aggressive pursuit of terrorists suspects. In the place of these either/or choices, the authors stress the importance of managing inherent tensions and striking careful balances.

I'm not sure precisely how to apply these observations (though I took a stab recently at a respectful exchange on the question of sanctions), Maybe the key thing to say is that a resevoir of goodwill, personal relationships, and experience with cooperation do exist within the foreign policy community.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c04d69e20148c7948821970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A More Civil Discourse -- Foreign Policy Wonks' Edition:

Comments

This is a great post. i will bookmark this page for reference. Keep it up and hope to read more of you soon.


Thanks,
Beginner Violin

Welcome to our website, and you will find the boots are very comfortable and beautiful.http://www.etoboots.com

From Basingstoke, where it started more than a century ago, to Berlin,
the Burberry outlet story just keeps getting better. Burberry boss
Angela Ahrendts was crowned retail queen at the World Retail Congress in
the German city last week when she was given the Outstanding Leadership
Award for her work in turning around the beige-black-red-and white
scarf and trench-coat maker; it is now one of the world’s most
sought-after brands. Ahrendts told the audience that part of Burberry
scarf ‘s success has been in going digital, with more than two million
Facebook fans able to watch most of its catwalk shows live. Whether
Ahrendts, who has seen the shares nearly triple to 1,020p on her watch,
can keep marching at this pace is the big unknown; the answerh lies
somewhere in the East, where she is expanding fast.

With this King leading the Roundheads against the Cavaliers, can the Puritans win?


Mervyn King, the Governor of the Bank of England,burberry scarf hasn’t lost his
touch. In New York last week, he took his radical, if not puritanical,
ideas right to the heart of the powerful at the Buttonwood Gathering,
when he criticised the big banks and even hit out at the new Basel 3
rules as being too soft.

That was the gentle bit. If anyone
thought King was wavering in his belief that some sort of separation or
break-up of the banks is the thing to do, they should have heard the
next part of his speech: “Of all the many ways of organising banking,
the worst is the one we have today.” He went on to question our
fractional reserve banking system which has existed for centuries; the
way banks take in deposits and then – in such cavalier fashion – lend
them out for longer-term loans at higher risk; ie, leverage. In his own
words: “For all the clever innovation in the financial system,Pink Burberry Giant Check Scarf its
Achilles heel was, and remains, simply the extraordinary – indeed absurd
– levels of leverage represented by a heavy reliance on short-term
debt. ” As he added, any solution to this must ensure that the costs of
“maturity transformation” (the costs of bailouts) fall on those who
enjoy the benefits; the bankers.

This is fighting stuff, but then the future structure of banking is at stake, and the battle will be bloody.


The big question is: Which side will the Independent Banking Commission
take?Light Blue Burberry Giant Check Scarf If commissioners prove to be Roundheads and go for reform, will
they be brave enough to stand up to the firepower of the Cavaliers? Wall
Street and the City will fight furiously to keep the system exactly as
it is. But with this King leading the Roundhead charge, hopefully
they’ll show their mettle.

und the beige-black-red-and white
scarf and trench-coat maker; it is now one of the world’s most
sought-after brands. Ahrendts told the audience that part of Burberry
scarf ‘s success has been in going digital, with more than two million
Facebook fans able to watch most of its c

Ahrendts told the audience that part of Burberry
scarf ‘s success has been in going digital

n going digital, with more than two million
Facebook fans able to watch most of its c

more vigorous pursuit of internal networks that are used as useful in the future toward India. Afghanistan has nothing to do with

In the place of these either/or choices, the authors stress the importance of managing inherent tensions and striking careful balances.
seslisohbet seslichat

keep marching at this pace is the big unknown; the answerh lies
somewhere in the East, where she is expanding fast.

on her watch,
can keep marching at this pace is the big unknown; the answerh lies
somewhere in the East, where she is expanding fast.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Subscribe
Sign-up to receive a weekly digest of the latest posts from Democracy Arsenal.
Email: 
Powered by TypePad

Disclaimer

The opinions voiced on Democracy Arsenal are those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of any other organization or institution with which any author may be affiliated.
Read Terms of Use