Chasing Authenticity
Posted by Michael Signer
I unfortunately (or perhaps fortunately) can't write too much today, as I've gotten a little derailed at my day job, but wanted to chime in briefly on the very interesting debate about Joe Klein's new book. I haven't read Klein's book, but it seems like one of those books you really don't have to read to understand.
His thesis, summarized in this Time piece, is that politics has been ruined by think-inside-the-box consultants who take away Al Gore's passion for the environment, John Kerry's antiwar positions, and, to extend the logic, Bob Dole's humor. His peroration that concludes the piece is stirring:
I hate predictions. Most pundits, like most pollsters, get their information by looking in the rearview mirror. But let me give 2008 a try. The winner will be the candidate who comes closest to this model: a politician who refuses to be a "performer," at least in the current sense. Who speaks but doesn't orate. Who never holds a press conference on or in front of an aircraft carrier. Who doesn't assume the public is stupid or uncaring. Who believes in at least one major idea, or program, that has less than 40% support in the polls. Who can tell a joke—at his or her own expense, if possible. Who gets angry, within reason; gets weepy, within reason ... but only if those emotions are real and rare. Who isn't averse to kicking his or her opponent in the shins but does it gently and cleverly. Who radiates good sense, common decency and calm. Who is not afraid to deliver bad news. Who is not afraid to admit a mistake. And who, above all, abides by the motto that graced Franklin Delano Roosevelt's Oval Office: let unconquerable gladness dwell.
Good as it sounds, though, there are problems with all of this.
First, as a stimulating debate on Slate between the Daily Kos and Stuart Stevens illuminates, Klein's empirical emphasis is somewhat misplaced and perhaps misguided. He idealizes Bobby Kennedy's speech after MLK's death as the example par excellence of non-consultant-driven politics -- but this was a rare and perhaps unique event, driven by a singular human tragedy, and was completely spontaneous. Were politics always to have to respond to this level of debate, it wouldn't be politics at all -- it would be constant emergency. We couldn't sustain that level of energy and adrenaline, and of the rhetoric entailed. So RFK's speech was necessarily singular and generational.
And we do see similar examples of inspired rhetoric, anyway -- whether the convention speeches by Barack Obama "Audacity of Hope" speech in 2004 and Mario Cuomo's "Tale of Two Cities" address in 1984 -- or even the more ordinary but still moving, like a recent C-SPAN interview by Brian Lamb with my former boss Mark Warner, where Governor Warner talked movingly about his mother's battle with Alzheimer's disease.
There's a deeper problem, which I actually wrote about in a WaPo op-ed a couple years back, when I was interested in the worshipping of Howard Dean's "straight-talking." Because everyone -- including Joe Klein -- acknowledges that modern (or perhaps all) politics is intrinsically theatrical, the pursuit of authenticity actually just generates a circular paradox. We want people to convince us they are authentic -- but we don't necessarily want them to be authentic. And then, of course, when they're actually authentic (like George W. Bush scowling during the first debate with John Kerry) far be it from someone like Klein to praise him for it.
There's much more to say about this but, like I said, I gotta go. Authentically.
Seems to me Klein could have just written "The key thing in politics is authenticity. If you can learn to fake that, you've got it made." Would have saved plenty of trees.
Posted by: jayinbmore | May 19, 2006 at 01:19 PM
Saved trees and been right, too. The problem Democratic activists have picking candidates is that we are issue oriented but a critical number of voters, particularly independents, are not. A critical number of voters vote for, not authenticity, but perceived trustworthiness. They will vote against their own issues for the candidate who seems, when viewed on TV, to be trustworthy. It is not possible to win a national election without getting the votes of these folks, like it or not.
Klien is right: fire the consultants. And all of us who plan to take part in the chosing of the next Democratic candidate MUST think in terms of how well that candidate can pull independent voters, remembering that those voters are moved by style, not content. In other words, there is no need to "move to the middle" on issues. In fact, that's counterproductive since it makes the politician look like a panderer. We need someone who is right on the issues to please us annd has the right persona on TV to please the independents.
And that is absolutely not Hillary Clinton. She has no perceived trustworthiness at all because she is the kind of politician who gets her opinions from the opinion polls and never says anything without having a crew of consultants wordsmith her commmets first. We have lots of candidates who could win; she's the only guarranteed loser because independents won't vote for her in large enough numbers to win an election.
Posted by: lily | May 21, 2006 at 01:06 PM
omni casino -
palace of chance -
party bingo -
party casino -
party poker -
piggs casino -
piggs peak -
planet luck -
poker 333 -
poker metro -
poke round -
rich webmaster -
river nile casino -
roxy palace -
roxy poker -
ruby fortune -
sail away casino -
s casino -
sci fi casino -
slots alley casino -
slots royale -
spass kasino -
spin palace -
spin palace poker -
star luck casino -
sterling house casino -
sun poker -
swiss casino -
the sands -
the sands of the caribbean -
three diamonds casino -
tiki bingo -
uk casino club -
vegas break casino -
vegas splendido -
vip -
vip casinos -
vip horses -
vip poker -
vip profits -
vip soccer -
vip sports -
wager junction -
wager profits -
wssb casino -
wssb sport -
action gold -
action poker -
affiliate lounge -
all jackpots -
all slots -
amber coast casino -
apues tas -
aus vegas -
bella vegas -
bet bet -
bet casino -
bet holdem -
bets son -
bet wwts -
big bettys bingo -
bingo 777 -
bingo cafe -
bingo fantasy -
bingo for money -
bingo hall -
bingo liner -
bingo palace -
bingo reward -
bright right -
cash wave -
casino domain -
casino euro -
casino lucky dog -
casino pay check -
casino webcam -
cherry casino -
city club casino -
cyber sportsbook -
diamond gal -
earn united -
first web casino -
fortune junction -
geisha bingo -
giant vegas -
go casino -
gold betting -
grand bay -
grand bay poker -
grand casino royale -
grand riviera -
hampton casino -
hotel casino network -
internet bingo -
jackpot factory -
jackpot joy -
jackpot wheel -
jet bingo -
juegos 65 -
jupiter club -
king netpunes casino -
lady dream -
lake palace -
mahjong time -
merlins magic casino -
oasis casino -
online vegas -
only bingo -
oyna 65 -
paradise affiliates -
paradise poker -
play 65 -
player vegas -
play united -
poker -
poker cs -
poker in canada -
poker share -
portofino casino -
race track casino -
refer bingo -
refer spot -
revenue giants -
royal dice -
sandpiper casino -
shark casino -
sierra star casino -
slots village -
speed bet -
tcads -
the six shooter -
the star casino -
tiger gaming -
top card casino -
top line bingo -
trident lounge -
trident poker -
triple win -
ultimate bet -
vegas experts -
vegas usa -
vics bingo -
wild jack casino -
wild jack mobile -
wild jack poker -
winward casino -
24h poker -
400 affiliates -
9 am -
9 games -
9 poker -
absolute poker -
acf webmaster -
acropolis casinos -
atlantic lounge -
bet 365 -
bet 365 poker -
bet com -
bet fred -
bet max casino -
bet on usa -
bingo bank roll -
bingo cabin -
bingo program -
bingo promoter -
bingo royalty -
bingos -
bingos uk -
canadas best bingo -
can bet -
canbet casino -
canbet poker -
canbet sports -
capital bingo -
casino 365 -
casino 770 -
casino controller -
casino partouche -
casino room -
celeb poker -
cindys poker -
club euro casino -
club uk casino -
club usa casino -
cocoa casino -
crystal palace casino -
da vincis gold -
diamond deal casino -
ecard room -
el bingo -
euro poker -
festive bingo -
galactic bingo -
gaming income -
giga slot -
global player -
gran casino royale -
holdem poker -
i net bet -
inter champs -
island poker -
jackpot palace -
ladies bingo -
las seters -
las vegas usa casino -
metro casino -
my bookie -
nine -
nine am -
nine games -
nine poker -
pacific poker -
paradise 8 -
paradise eight -
pharaohs casino -
play and deal -
players club casino -
poker affiliate -
poker room -
pure slots -
purple lounge -
pyramid casino -
rock my wallet -
royal card club -
sia casino -
slot fever casino -
slot land -
slots -
slots 24 -
slots cr -
slots plus -
stars and stripes bingo -
sun palace casino -
sunset casino -
this is vegas -
touch stone poker -
true earnings -
twin aces casino -
vc casino -
vc poker -
vegas casino online -
vegas lucky -
vegas magic -
victor -
victor chandler casino -
video poker classic -
24kt gold casino -
777 dragon -
7 sultans -
7 sutlans poker -
aces high -
all poker casino -
aposte -
arthurian casino -
aspinalls online casino -
aztec riches casino -
aztec riches poker -
blackjack ballroom -
cameo casino -
captain cooks casino -
captain cooks poker -
caribbean gold -
casino blasters -
casino bleu blanc rouge -
casino classic -
casino coins -
casino del rio -
casino kingdom -
casino partners -
casino rewards -
casino tropez -
casino us -
cinema casino -
college poker championship -
colosseum casino -
crazy vegas casino -
crazy vegas poker -
desert dollar -
diamond casino -
english habour -
english habour poker -
english habour uk -
europa casino -
flamingo club -
fortune affiliates -
fortune lounge -
fortune room -
gaming club -
gaming club poker -
gaming club uk -
golden palace -
golden palace bingo -
golden palace mobile -
golden palace poker -
golden tiger casino -
golden tiger poker -
gold nugget casino -
grand hotel casino -
grand online -
grand prix lotto -
hammers casino -
havana club -
home casino -
isa bet -
jackpot city -
lucky emperor -
lucky nugget -
lucky nugget casino uk -
lucky nugget poker -
maple casino -
millionaire casino -
online casino -
orbital casino -
phoenician casino -
platinum play -
play 4 free -
poker forum challenge -
poker ocean -
poker rewards -
poker time -
refer back -
rewards parking -
river belle -
river belle poker -
royal vegas -
royal vegas poker -
seven sultans -
showdown casino -
silver dollar -
silver dollar casino -
strike it lucky casino -
sun vegas -
super slots -
super slots bingo -
titan poker -
vegas affiliates -
vegas country casino -
vegas palms -
vegas partner -
vegas red -
vegas towers -
vegas villa -
virtual city casino -
virtual city poker -
yukon gold casino -
zodiac casino -
32 vegas -
3 diamonds casino -
49er casino -
50 stars casino -
888 -
888 casino -
ace club -
black widow casino -
caribbean sun poker -
carnival casino -
car sands -
casino fortune -
casino fortune uk -
casino france net -
casino king -
casino las vegas -
casino mb -
casino onliner -
casino on net -
casino pays -
casino profit share -
cd casino -
cd poker -
challenge casino -
cirrus casino -
club dice casino -
club dice poker -
club player casino -
cool cat casino -
cs casino -
diamond club casino -
diamond club poker -
empire poker -
fair poker -
gambling wages -
golden reef casino -
golden riviera casino -
golden riviera poker -
gold gate casino -
gold key casino -
grand banks casino -
i play tournaments -
joyland casino -
luck n roll casino -
mad bingo -
magic box casino -
magic oasis -
mapau -
mapau bingo -
mapau de -
miami beach -
miami paradise casino -
miss bingo -
monaco gold casino -
music hall casino -
new york casino -
noble poker -
nostalgia casinos -
omni casino -
palace of chance -
party bingo -
party casino -
party poker -
peach casino -
planet luck -
playgate casino -
playgate poker -
poker metro -
poke round -
poker show -
prestige bingo -
prestige casino -
prestige poker -
rich webmaster -
river nile casino -
royal plaza casino -
ruby bingo -
ruby bingo uk -
s casino -
slots alley casino -
slots royale -
spass kasino -
sports interaction -
star luck casino -
sterling house casino -
sunny diamonds -
sun palace -
swiss casino -
the sands -
the sands of the caribbean -
three diamonds casino -
uk casino club -
usa casino -
vegas 7 casino -
vegas joker casino -
vegas seven casino -
vegas slot casino -
wager junction -
windows casino -
you bingo -
all jackpots -
all star affiliates -
aus vegas -
bella vegas -
bet 19 -
bet bet -
bet casino -
bet euro -
bet game day -
bet holdem -
bet on games -
bet on races -
bet wwts -
big bettys bingo -
bingo 777 -
bingo fantasy -
black pool bingo -
break away casino -
bright right -
cabaret club casino -
cash wave -
casino hotel network -
casino lucky dog -
casino pay check -
casino verano -
casino webcam -
city club casino -
cyber sportsbook -
diamond gal -
earn united -
fair deal sports -
fast win casino -
five card charlie -
fortune junction -
geisha lounge -
go casino -
gold betting -
good as gold casino -
grand aces -
grand bay -
grand bay poker -
grand casino royale -
grand riviera -
jackpot joy -
jackpots in a flash -
jackpot wheel -
jupiter club -
king neptunes casino -
king solomons -
kiwi bingo -
kiwi bingo uk -
kiwi casino -
kiwi casino poker -
lady dream -
lake palace -
mahjong time -
merlins magic casino -
mummys gold -
online vegas -
only bingo -
piggs casino -
piggs peak -
players vegas -
play united -
poker 333 -
poker share -
race track casino -
refer spot -
roxy palace -
roxy poker -
ruby fortune -
sail away casino -
sandpiper casino -
sci fi casino -
shark casino -
spin palace -
spin palace poker -
the six shooter -
the star casino -
tiki bingo -
top card casino -
top line bingo -
trident lounge -
trident poker -
triple win -
ultimate bet -
vegas break casino -
vegas experts -
vegas splendido -
vegas usa -
vip -
vip casinos -
vip horses -
vip poker -
vip profits -
vip soccer -
vip sports -
wager profits -
wssb casino -
wssb sport -
9 am -
9 games -
9 poker -
acf webmaster -
action gold -
action poker -
affiliate lounge -
all slots -
amber coast casino -
apues tas -
atlantic lounge -
bet 365 -
bet 365 poker -
bet com -
bet on usa -
bets son -
bingo bank roll -
bingo cabin -
bingo cafe -
bingo for money -
bingo hall -
bingo liner -
bingo palace -
bingo program -
bingo reward -
bingo royalty -
bingos -
bingos uk -
canadas best bingo -
captial bingo -
casino 365 -
casino 770 -
casino domain -
casino euro -
casino partouche -
cherry casino -
cindys poker -
crystal palace casino -
diamond club casino -
el bingo -
festive bingo -
first web casino -
galactic bingo -
gaming income -
geisha bingo -
giant vegas -
giga slot -
gran casino espana -
hampton casino -
i net bet -
inter champs -
internet bingo -
jackpot factory -
jet bingo -
juegos 65 -
las vegas usa casino -
my bookie -
nine -
nine am -
nine games -
nine poker -
oasis casino -
oyna 65 -
paradise affiliates -
paradise poker -
play 65 -
play and deal -
poker -
poker cs -
poker in canada -
portofino casino -
pure slots -
purple lounge -
pyramid casino -
refer bingo -
revenue giants -
rock my wallet -
royal card club -
Posted by: grace | November 02, 2007 at 02:07 PM
There are certain things in life related to smoking that simply cannot :)
parça kontör
parça kontör bayiliği
parça kontör bayilik
Posted by: kamil | December 19, 2008 at 12:36 PM
There is a lot of aion online gold in the game,if you want to have them you can come to play the game. Ilike to earn the aion money,because if i have them i can go to buy equipment and i also can go to buy aion gold. if you want to play it, please cheap aion gold and join us. Please do not hesitate to play the game,i believe you will like it too.
Posted by: aion gold | December 25, 2008 at 02:28 AM
Yesterday, my boyfriend gave me a lot of Pirates of the Burning Sea Gold and I buy potbs Doubloon as the gift to return him. The potbs gold is attractive and I have plenty of the potbs Doubloon.
Posted by: potbs money | January 06, 2009 at 08:17 PM
I hope i can get sro gold in low price.
i buy silkroad online gold for you.
Posted by: silkroad gold | January 19, 2009 at 08:14 PM
Once I played wonderland, I did not know how to get strong, someone told me that you must have wonderland online Gold. He gave me some Runes of Magic Gold.
Posted by: wonderland online Gold | February 13, 2009 at 10:35 PM
I do not want to rely on my parents cheap Tales Of Pirates gold. They look after me so long time, they pay me too much and very tired buy Tales Of Pirates Gold.
Posted by: cheap Tales Of Pirates gold | March 03, 2009 at 10:35 PM
Do you like playing the game where you need to use wow gold, when you do not have World of Warcraft Gold,
Posted by: wow gold | March 19, 2009 at 11:15 PM
I am so with you,rolex watch
luxury watch
Posted by: luxury watches | June 05, 2009 at 06:44 AM
bonuses without deposit stod uden udbetaling gratiale - giver alle nye spillere $50 uden cash 50 indskud
depósito poker fifty dollar bônus
dinheiro gratuito - brasil online poker money no deposit without poker
lklk poker soft - poker cash no deposit
Posted by: kjij | July 03, 2009 at 07:58 PM
online soft poker no deposit bonus free gambling cash and money forte no required deposit
online poker bonuses and money for free.
Music poker pokernot eton lose you belong erfef and chips omaha holdem. Nice cards you have.
Posted by: green pkr bonus | July 03, 2009 at 08:06 PM
Thank you for your sharing! I like i very much!
Posted by: cheap coach handbags | January 26, 2010 at 10:28 PM
Great post. I was tempting in starting a music section on a personal blog
Posted by: Bike | September 27, 2011 at 10:32 AM